Chernobyl is not about nuclear energy. Chernobyl is about Russian communism.
It was about the worst possible nuclear disaster that could ever happen. It would be difficult to reproduce it anywhere else. It would be really difficult to reproduce the level of incompetence and mismanagement, characteristic of the late Soviet system. (That incompetence is of course in no way contradictory to the real heroism of many concerned, as often in the Russian history.)
Chernobyl disaster was probably the worst possible nuclear disaster. And still, it has caused about the same number of victims as, for example, the Bhopal chemical disaster. (Anybody remembers that one ?). And it has caused an order of magnitude less victims than the worst hydroelectric power station disaster, the Banqiao Dam Collapse. (By the way, the soviets have participated in the Bangiao dam design too.)
Chernobyl disaster is not an argument against the nuclear power.
In fact, it is an argument for the nuclear power.
"The lesson of Chernobyl isn’t that modern nuclear power is dangerous. The lesson is that lying, arrogance, and suppression of criticism are dangerous.”
-- Craig Mazin, writer and director of HBO’s Chernobyl
No comments:
Post a Comment